Welcome to NEFF

Sign up for a new account today, or log on with your old account!

Give us a try!

Welcome back to the new NEFF. Take a break from Twitter and Facebook. You don't go to Dicks for your fly fishing gear, you go to your local fly fishing store. Enjoy!

The true cost of non-native trout

mbwmn

“Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?”
I have seen or fished most of these waters around Glacier NP...

The true cost of non-native trout - Hungry Horse News: Columns

By CHRIS SCHUSTROM and BRUCE FARLING<!-- AP Content -->This spring, native westslope cutthroat and bull trout will stage for their epic journeys from Flathead Lake to spawning streams in the Middle and North Forks Flathead River. Once quite common, their numbers are significantly diminished from the recent past because many cannot navigate the gauntlet of predacious non-native lake trout (and illegally introduced northern pike) that occupy the lake and river.
Our neighbors, the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes, want to bolster the populations of native fish to once again provide a diverse sport fishery as well as revive an important part of tribal culture. With the support of anglers, the assistance of objective science and a review panel of biologists from state and federal agencies, as well as the university system, the tribes are working hard to strike a reasonable balance in the fishery at Flathead Lake. They deserve your support.
<!-- There are no ads assigned to position -->

Flathead Lake once hosted one of Montana’s most popular and robust sport fisheries, featuring millions of kokanee salmon, cutthroats, yellow perch, bull trout and lake trout. Today, the salmon are gone and cutthroat and bull trout numbers have been reduced dramatically. Also gone are many fishermen. Perch and lake whitefish remain, but their availability fluctuates year to year, depending on water levels and predation.
Well-meaning state managers who introduced mysis shrimp into the Flathead system in the 1980s triggered the decline in the lake’s fishery and fishing opportunities. The shrimp provide an ample food source for young lake trout, improving their survival rates. Once these lake trout get larger, they feed on other fish.
In the ‘90s, the exploding lake trout population consumed about 10 million kokanee in Flathead Lake, collapsing perhaps the most popular lake fishery in the state. Angling numbers then dropped by about 50 percent. When the kokanee disappeared, so did hundreds of bald eagles that gathered each fall to gorge on spawning salmon at McDonald Creek in Glacier National Park. Thousands of tourists then stopped coming to view the eagles. Tourism dollars dropped.
-more-
 
Yeah lake trout suck big ones. Cutthroat will most likely be non existent in twenty years or so. The biggest threat is hybridization though. Every year you see more and more cutt-bows. Its cool to catch a cutthroat every once in a while, but they kinda fight like pussies. Bull trout on the other hand is freakin awesome
 
Lake Hopatcong is also a victim of the same BS. The small baitfish are getting scarce, too many predator fish have been newly added....Muskie, walleye, hybrid bass....all of which will severely impact the baitfissh and largemouth bass population. .
 
Lake Hopatcong is also a victim of the same BS. The small baitfish are getting scarce, too many predator fish have been newly added....Muskie, walleye, hybrid bass....all of which will severely impact the baitfissh and largemouth bass population. .

The largemouth bass are non-native as well as all the others in that lake. Perhaps chain pickerel and yellow perch existed when it was two small lakes with the Musconetcong River flowing through them. We keep playing God with our fisheries and remain surprised negatively by the end results. Like I said earlier, when will we learn? At least the oceans have few non-natives wreaking havoc, they "only" have to deal with over harvesting.
 
The largemouth bass are non-native as well as all the others in that lake. Perhaps chain pickerel and yellow perch existed when it was two small lakes with the Musconetcong River flowing through them. We keep playing God with our fisheries and remain surprised negatively by the end results. Like I said earlier, when will we learn? At least the oceans have few non-natives wreaking havoc, they "only" have to deal with over harvesting.

True Rusty, but the largemouth bass population had been established for decades....... The introduction of 3 new predator fish two of which grow far larger than largemouth bass will damage the now established population of bass... I have seen first hand big ass muskie take spawining bass off their nest.
 
True Rusty, but the largemouth bass population had been established for decades....... The introduction of 3 new predator fish two of which grow far larger than largemouth bass will damage the now established population of bass... I have seen first hand big ass muskie take spawining bass off their nest.

It seems with introducing non native fish species, if some are good, then more must be better. That seems never to be the case, but we never learn that lesson.
 
The largemouth bass are non-native as well as all the others in that lake. Perhaps chain pickerel and yellow perch existed when it was two small lakes with the Musconetcong River flowing through them. We keep playing God with our fisheries and remain surprised negatively by the end results. Like I said earlier, when will we learn? At least the oceans have few non-natives wreaking havoc, they "only" have to deal with over harvesting.
Actually Lake Hopatcong had very good pickerel fishing in the 1950s.

Possibly a better example:

As a student, I worked summers at Silver Lake Camp (now part of the Hamburg Mountain WMA). The lake had an excellent pickerel and minnow population..... We had 8 year old kids catching 3 pounders regularly...

The caretaker didn't like pickerel (too many bones).

After I got out of the Army, I went back to visit.
He had "bucket stocked" the lake with Largemouths.
The minnows were gone.
The pickerel were almost gone.
Bass fishing was mediocre..
 
Actually Lake Hopatcong had very good pickerel fishing in the 1950s.

Possibly a better example:

As a student, I worked summers at Silver Lake Camp (now part of the Hamburg Mountain WMA). The lake had an excellent pickerel and minnow population..... We had 8 year old kids catching 3 pounders regularly...

The caretaker didn't like pickerel (too many bones).

After I got out of the Army, I went back to visit.
He had "bucket stocked" the lake with Largemouths.
The minnows were gone.
The pickerel were almost gone.
Bass fishing was mediocre..

Pickerel fishing in Lake Hopatcong was excellent in the 80's, we used to drift from the Windlass and Dow's boat rental to brady's bridge using small sunnies we caught with a drag net, didn't know we were breaking the law but it worked great.
 
Pickerel fishing in Lake Hopatcong was excellent in the 80's, we used to drift from the Windlass and Dow's boat rental to brady's bridge using small sunnies we caught with a drag net, didn't know we were breaking the law but it worked great.

You got that right...we used to ice fish off of Dow's and regularly catch beautiful big pickerel. Same thing down on the Windlass side of Brady's bridge.

As for too boney, run the fillets through a meat grinder add some ground potato with bread crumbs and seasoning. Hmmm, pickerel patty...
 
As for too boney, run the fillets through a meat grinder add some ground potato with bread crumbs and seasoning. Hmmm, pickerel patty...

Pickled pickerel is not only delicious, but will melt some of those small bones that are a bitch to get out......It works great for pike as well. It is mighty delicious and sounds good too...PICKLED PICKEREL...MMMMM
 
Pickled pickerel is not only delicious, but will melt some of those small bones that are a bitch to get out......It works great for pike as well. It is mighty delicious and sounds good too...PICKLED PICKEREL...MMMMM

I've also smoked pickerel, just took a few tries to figure out which end to light.
 
Back
Top